Surfshark VPN vs PureVPN: Which is better?

Surfshark and PureVPN logos

Surfshark or PureVPN?

It's a question a lot of people are asking and if you're one of them then below, you'll learn what sets them apart. But more importantly, which is the right choice for your needs.

Choosing the correct VPN is incredibly important, as well as very tricky in today's VPN market.

It is important because you need to make sure that you will be adequately protected and have the types of features available for your usage.

On the other hand, it is difficult because there are so many VPNs out there, that it is nothing short of confusing.

We lost count somewhere around 500, but there are plenty more on top.

Today, we are going to compare two trendy and well-known names in the VPN industry and see if they are as good as they claim.

Along the way, we will also see how they compare, which will give you some idea of which one to go for.

If you can't wait, you can skip to the results here.

Logging

Surfshark

When it comes to our first category, logging, Surfshark is one of the leading options.

The service has a strict no-logging policy, and it is even based in a privacy-friendly jurisdiction, but we will talk more about that later on.

For now, all that matters is to note that Surfshark is not a VPN that will record or sell your data, and as such, it is deserving of your trust.

Surfshark logging

Surfshark is unaudited but its logging policy is clear.

It's worth noting that although Surfshark's browser extensions have been audited, this does not currently extend to their service or logging claims. One worth remembering.

PureVPN

PureVPN claims not to hold logs, although this service has some controversial past regarding logging. As a result, a lot of people are not sure whether or not to trust it to this very day.

The incident with the service happened in late 2017 when the FBI managed to identify a person who used PureVPN.

The individual in question was guilty of online harassment, but as a VPN user, they were supposed to be safe. They were not.

PureVPN no logs text

PureVPN also claims not to store any of your details.

Since then, PureVPN worked on becoming better and it managed to get a certificate that confirms that it doesn't keep logs.

However, it is hard to shake off a bad reputation, and the service might never get everyone to trust it again.

Winner: Surfshark

Surfshark hasn't yet undertaken an audit of their service to prove their “no log” claims. However, with a sketchy history, PureVPN isn't one we can recommend in this area.

30-day money back guarantee

Streaming

Surfshark

Next up, we have streaming, which is something that Surfshark is very good at.

The service offers an extensive server network that spans throughout 63 countries.

Meanwhile, it offers 1,700 servers in total. With Surfshark being relatively new it means that the big streaming services haven't blocked most of these servers.

Due to this, it works well with Netflix, Disney+, BBC iPlayer and all the other big popular streaming services.

The standout feature is they unlock many more Netflix regions than most of the competition. Not to mention that it has servers in countries where most other VPNs do not, such as Russia.

PureVPN

PureVPN also seems to be functional when it comes to unblocking Netflix, and you definitely should not have any troubles when it comes to its speeds.

After all, PureVPN does call itself ‘the world's fastest VPN'.

One thing that is going for it is having a massive server network that covers 180 locations in 135 countries and offers over 2,000 servers in total. It has 300,000 IP addresses for you to go through.

In our tests, we didn't have any problems with the major streaming services, although you may need to connect a couple of times to find a working server.

Winner: It's a tie!

While PureVPN does have more servers in more locations around the world, we believe that the two are equally good when it comes to streaming.

They are both capable of unblocking some of the most popular streaming services in the world, which means that it doesn't really matter which one you pick if this is what you need a VPN for.

Concurrent Connections

PureVPN

Let's start with PureVPN. When it comes to concurrent connections, this service used to allow 5 simultaneous connections at once.

However, it recently expanded that number, and they doubled it. It now lets you use it on as many as 10 different devices simultaneously, which is excellent for anyone who has many different devices that they use concurrently.

PureVPN device limit

It is even better for those who wish to pay one license and protect their entire family with it.

Surfshark

Surfshark has bucked the industry trend and instead of limiting the number of devices you can use, they have zero limits.

That's right – with Surfshark, you pay for a VPN plan, and you get to use it on as many devices as you could desire.

Surfshark devices

This will let you protect your entire family at once, and you can protect every device that your family owns, with no limits at all.

Winner: Surfshark

This one doesn't need any particular explanations.

PureVPN covers 10 devices at the same time, and while that is great on its own, it pales in comparison with Surfshark's infinite concurrent connections. Surfshark wins this one.

30-day money back guarantee

Apps

Surfshark

Next, let's talk about apps. As mentioned, Surfshark allows you to use them on an unlimited number of devices, but which devices does it actually support?

Well, the answer is – all the popular ones and more. You will find apps for:

  • Windows
  • Mac
  • Linux
  • Android
  • iOS
  • Chrome
  • Firefox
  • Fire TV

You'll also find set-up guides and support for:

  • Apple TV
  • Other TVs
  • Xbox
  • PlayStation

All of its apps offer excellent features, such as ad blockers, tracker blockers, as well as protection against phishing and malware.

There are also features such as Whitelister, a kill switch, DNS and leak protection, camouflage mode, and more.

PureVPN

PureVPN also supports a wide range of devices with dedicated apps and extensions for:

  • Windows
  • macOS
  • Linux
  • Android
  • iOS
  • Chrome
  • Firefox

They also offer support and guides for setting up on the following devices:

  • Android TV
  • Kodi
  • Roku
  • AppleTV
  • Firestick
  • Routers
  • Browsers
  • PlayStation
  • Xbox
  • Raspberry Pi
  • Now TV Box
  • Boxee box

And that's not all. Apart from covering all of these devices, PureVPN also offers plenty of different features, including a kill switch and split tunnelling.

Winner: It's a tie!

Both of these VPNs are excellent when it comes to the quality of their apps.

While PureVPN offers more guides for various platforms than Surfshark, both are pretty much near-unlimited thanks to the fact that they have browser support, and browsers like Chrome can be used on almost every device that has an internet connection.

They both have dedicated apps for a similar number of devices so ultimately it's impossible to separate them – it's a draw.

Jurisdiction

Surfshark

Jurisdiction is an essential part of a VPN, especially these days when online surveillance is extreme in some regions.

With an entire 14 Eyes alliance out there – not to mention additional countries that collaborate with the members of the coalition, securing the privacy of your information is more critical than ever.

As mentioned, Surfshark already doesn't keep logs, which is good.

However, the fact that it is based in the British Virgin Islands is even better.

As such, it is out of the reach of the 14 Eyes alliance, and in a privacy-friendly nation where no one will appear with a court order, demanding that they surrender the data of their users.

PureVPN

On the other hand, we have PureVPN, which is based in Hong Kong.

Now, at first glance, this is extremely bad. However, the situation is much better than it seems. Everyone knows how intrusive China is, but Hong Kong plays by different rules.

It has managed to keep its own privacy laws instead of obeying those that are pulling the rest of the country down. As such, Hong Kong doesn't suffer from the same restrictions, nor does it have to provide data to the rest of China.

And, of course, it is outside of the 14 Eyes alliance's reach, which is also very good for anyone who wishes to use it.

However, if you're concerned about the ever expanding reach of mainland China into Hong Kong, you may want to give this one a miss.

Winner: It's a tie!

Once again, the two services are both located in privacy-friendly jurisdictions for now.

This may change depending on mainland China's influence on Hong Kong in the future. However, we would expect PureVPN to move jurisdiction if this were ever to happen.

Price

Surfshark

Lastly, let's discuss the prices of both of these services.

The prices are relevant as well, as plenty of times, equally good VPNs have different prices to them, and you shouldn't pay more when you can get the same quality for a cheaper amount of money.

When it comes to Surfshark, the service is somewhat cheaper than others that are considered the best in the industry. It has three different plans that look like this:

  • 1-month plan for $11.95 per month
  • 1-year plan for $5,99 per month (save 50%)
  • 2-year plan for $1.99 per month (save 83%)

Surfshark prices

As you can see, Surfshark offers a rather excellent deal, one that will allow you to pay only $2 per month if you are ready to pay for two years worth of VPN.

We should note, however, that you have to pay long-term plans at once, instead of paying $2 every month, but that's the deal with every VPN out there, and these prices are only here to show you the actual size of the discounts.

Lastly, it's worth remembering that Surfshark offers a 30-day money-back guarantee, just so that you would have more than enough time to test it and request your money back if it doesn't suit your needs.

PureVPN

Now, let's see how PureVPN compares. Without further ado, here are its plans and prices:

  • 7-day trial for $0.99, with the monthly cost being $5.82 per month afterwards (47% off)
  • 1-month plan for $10.95 per month
  • 6-month plan for $8.33 per month (save 24%)

However, it does seem to alternate with different plans that include a 1-month plan, 1-year plan and 2-year plans. It's all a little bit confusing.

PureVPN pricing

As you can see, unlike Surfshark, PureVPN is more oriented towards cheaper, short-term plans.

Its monthly price is $1 cheaper than that of Surfshark, and it even offers a $1 7-day trial, after which the price of a monthly plan is 47% lower.

This is great for users who only need a VPN for a month or two, for an extended vacation or an upcoming period filled with business trips or big sporting events.

And, if you don't want to have to think about renewing your license every month, you can just pay for half a year at the time, and gain an additional discount.

Winner: PureVPN

Considering that one VPN aims to be there for you longer, and the other one allows for greater convenience when choosing the length of your subscription, we should call it a tie here.

However, based on monthly prices, we have to call PureVPN a winner, as it offers a lower price than Surfshark.

Not only that, but you can even get a massive discount on it if you choose a 7-day trial that costs $1 first.

Overall Winner: Surfshark

Based on what we have seen, these two VPNs are pretty much in a tie, but Surfshark did manage to perform a bit better in some areas, which is what brought its overall victory.

However, it's still worth remembering that, while Surfshark may be a bit better based on the aspects we looked into here, the two services are pretty evenly matched.

With the two services neither stands out above the other but Surfshark just pips it making it an easy decision to choose between them.

Conclusion

And, that's it for this comparison.

While the services are incredibly close in terms of quality, Surfshark is our overall winner.

It's worth remembering that they have a 30-day money back guarantee. This allows you to trial their service for an entire month and if you don't agree with our assessment or it just isn't what you need then you can get a full refund.

You can then give PureVPN a try.

Or why not find out what separates two industry giants in our ExpressVPN vs NordVPN comparison. Or check out our full Surfshark review to learn more about their features in-depth.

 

Check out the winner. Get our Recommended VPN service!

  • Cheap prices
  • Multiple devices
  • Simple to use

Ali Raza

Author: Ali Raza

Ali is a journalist with a keen interest in VPN usage. He is an expert in the field and has been covering VPN related topics for VPNCompare and numerous well-respected publications for many years.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up to our newsletter

Get the latest privacy news, expert VPN guides & TV unblocking how-to’s sent straight to your inbox.